Mister Rogers paints with water colors. He talks about how he is sometimes unhappy that Mr. McFeely can’t stay long. Mister Rogers finds two pieces of chalk on his porch. Peggy Lipschutz uses the chalk for drawing while Vivien Richman sings. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Coach Saunders exercises with X and Daniel.

Mister Rogers pretends to be a bull, with his fingers as horns, and with some handlebars he brought. The handlebars fit into an exercise machine. He demonstrates running in place and lifting weights. Betty Aberlin stops in to borrow some sugar for the castle in the Neighborhood of Make Believe. In the Neighborhood of Make Believe, King Friday wears his best crown for his appointment with Sara Saturday. She admires his eyes, not his crown. She has made him some custard as a thank-you for allowing her to stay when she was frightened by the monster. King Friday wants her to stay longer.

Mister Rogers receives an invitation to a reception at the castle in honor of Sara Saturday. He writes a reply accepting the invitation. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Handyman Negri and Daniel discuss plans for the reception. Handyman doesn’t have anything to wear so he goes to the Museum-Go-Round’s men’s fashion show to decide what to wear. Costumes such as a caveman’s fur, a suit of armor, and a Venetian suit are modeled. He decides on a tuxedo with tails.

Mister Rogers wears a tuxedo for the reception in the Neighborhood of Make-believe. In the Neighborhood of Make-believe, Corny doesn’t go to the reception because he has too much work to do. X, Henrietta, Daniel, Sara Saturday, and King Friday go to the reception. Lady Aberlin has arranged the entertainment by Monduel Banessia, congo drummer, Handyman Negri, classical guitarist, and Lynda Martha, baton twirler. King Friday does not immediately recognize Handyman Negri who is wearing a tuxedo. When Sara Saturday leaves after the entertainment, they all hope she will come back.